To invest in a box spring or to not invest in a box spring?
Box spring absorbs shocks for the mattress that leads to the naturally added height. These are normally chosen by the buyer preferring a high bed.
Whereas Box Springs cause health concerns, poor sleep, and back problems, while the sleeper might be thinking that the mattress is the actual problem – when it’s the box spring.
Several alternatives to box spring will provide a better footing for the mattress to set on. Alternatives like wood foundations, platform beds, and adjustable beds are better to consider.
But first, you need to figure out about the actual box spring, and what are the available alternatives to box spring? Below is the collection of best alternative ways to bed yourself in a good relaxing posture comfortably.
- What is a Box Spring?
- Why do we need a box spring?
- Box spring alternatives
What is a Box Spring?
A box spring is congruous to its name. It is a box filled with springs! A wooden frame that houses spring coils and is enclosed within a fabric. This description sums up what a typical box spring looks like. A box spring is used to prop up the mattress on a bed.
Why do we need a box spring?
Box springs were devised to help prevent the sulking of an otherwise soft mattress. Mattresses usually sulked under the weight of the sleepers, causing body aches. This problem led to the creation of box springs. They not only help in keeping the mattress firm yet flexible but also improve the longevity of your mattress. This bed base helps in raising the height of your bed, and in making it easier for you to climb in and out of bed. Better bed height and flexibility help you in getting a good night’s sleep.
But, do you really need to shell out extra bucks to get a good night’s sleep and a healthy, active body?
This is where box spring alternative ideas enter the scene. There are dozens of box spring alternatives available on the market that will provide you with an even better sleeping experience.
Box spring alternatives
1. Under-mattress slats
Under-mattress slats are placed underneath your mattress. They are balanced inside the frame of your bed and provide a decent amount of support to the mattress and the sleepers.
If you were to draw a parallel between under-mattress slats and box spring, under-mattress slats are a clear winner. Box springs are really heavy, as compared to slats. Moreover, box springs are heavy on the pocket too.
For more critical comparison with a boxed spring, under-mattress slats do not comprise of spring coils. As a result, they do not allow for free movement to the sleeper. Hence, Slatted frames are considered ideal as they allow breathability while giving necessary support for your body.
- Can be found easily in your nearest hardware store
- Extremely cheap
- Easy to install
- Light in weight
- Do not add extra height to your bed
- Might break under extensive stress
2. Putting the mattress directly on the floor
Putting your mattress directly on the floor is one of the best box spring alternative ideas. All you need is your mattress, a flat floor surface and you are all set to sleep. The flat floor provides you with an even surface. This promises anchor and firm support to your mattress.
In comparison to box springs, putting your mattress directly on the floor offers a lot of health benefits. This box spring alternative idea not only increases your blood circulation throughout the body but also improves posture. Your joint and backache problems will be solved in no time!
- Costs you nothing
- A cold floor prevents hot sleeping
- Aligns the spine in the most neutral position
- Mites and molds may pose a risk to your health while sleeping
- Poor air circulation under the mattress
- Sleeping on your side will lead to backaches
3. Milkcrate bed base
If you are a huge Pinterest fan and love to DIY your home stuff, then this alternative is just for you!
Recycle old wooden milk crates as wooden crates would be sturdier. Join a few milk crates together to form a bed base equal in dimension to the size of your mattress. Paint them and mount a plywood sheet to enhance this DIY box spring alternative’s durability.
If compared to a box spring, this alternative to box spring fares poorly. There is no robust support that can stand the weight of the mattress and the sleepers.
- A good way to recycle old milk crates
- Cheaper than purchasing a box spring
- Might not be able to support heavyweight sleepers
- The absence of spring coils reduces flexibility
4. Platform bed
Platform beds do not require any additional bed bases to support the mattress. It is a solid, raised platform that may contain a few wooden slats to support circulation under the mattress. It is a chic and contemporary style of setting up your bed, without the worry that it might sag.
When compared to box springs, platform beds are aesthetically pleasing and practical. However, they come with an exorbitant price tag.
- No need to invest in box spring frames
- Contemporary bedroom look
- Additional storage space underneath the bed
- Increased air circulation to the mattress
- Not easy on the pocket
- Low bed profile, which might not be suitable for people with aching joints
- Side sleepers may develop hip pain
5. Adjustable bed
Adjustable beds are not just limited to hospitals. The need to read, eat, and watch Netflix in bed has resulted in the growing demand for adjustable beds. They are multi-hinged and can be adjusted according to your lifestyle needs.
Want to improve blood circulation? Modify the bed accordingly. Like to sleep with your head elevated up, then an adjustable bed is a right choice for you.
An adjustable bed is a cut above other alternatives to box spring. This is because an adjustable bed is tractable and can be adapted to the lifestyle needs of the sleeper.
- Can be modified following your lifestyle needs
- Reduces the risk of Acid Reflux in GERD patients
- Better blood circulation leads to improved and sound sleep
- Exorbitantly priced
- Mechanical failure may render the bed useless
- The need to purchase a new mattress that complements the adjustable bed
6. Memory foam mattress
Memory foam mattresses have become a household name since their advent in the 1970s. These mattresses utilize the heat released by the body to mold into the shape of the sleeper, thereby providing an optimal level of comfort. However, memory foam mattresses might require box springs for additional support.
When compared to a spring box, memory foam comes across as a soft alternative to box spring. However, memory foam mattresses contour your body weight to provide for a truly cozy sleeping experience.
- Made up of ‘hypoallergenic’ material
- Provides cushioning thereby relieving body pain
- May get hot as it retains body heat
- Not ideal for sensitive people, as it gives off a chemical odor
- Slightly on the pricier side
7. Hybrid mattress
Realize that memory foam mattress might not be a good choice for you? Let us introduce you to another mattress box spring alternatives: A Hybrid mattress!
Hybrid mattresses combine the best qualities of memory foam mattresses along with the sturdy support of an innerspring system. These mattresses provide comfort and support like no other mattress system does.
The cushioning effect from memory foam and the spinal support from pocket wrapped coil systems is the ultimate dynamic duo.
A box spring is usually in the covering of a thin layer of fabric. On the contrary, hybrid mattresses normally have layers of latex and memory foam. These hybrids also consist of a top, gel-infused layer.
- Better air circulation due to the presence of Gelling agents in the cover layer
- The innerspring system provides a robust foundation, while the memory foam mattress alleviates back and joint pain
- Come with a steep price tag
- Very heavy in weight
8. Innerspring mattress
Innerspring mattresses simply diminish the need for a box spring, as they utilize a spring coil system within the mattress itself. It is flexible yet rigid at the same time. The spring coils absorb the pressure exerted by the lying body and distribute it evenly. The foam cover layer prevents the spring coils from feeling as if they are digging into your body. Innerspring mattresses are perfect rivals for box springs as they cut down on the cost of investing in an additional bed base.
- Provide aeration due to the presence of coils
- The mattress does not sulk under body weight
- Better durability
- Might be too rigid for some sleepers
- Lead to the development of joint pain inside sleepers
- Innerspring coils get noisier over time
9. Wood slat foundation
Wooden slats are joined together to form a bed foundation. A cheap box spring alternative that is durable and can be moved around very easily. Wood slats stop your mattress from sulking and sagging and provide the right amount of firm support to help you sleep better. Sitting horizontally to the frame of your bed, wood slats stop your mattress from moving around.
Wood slats are indeed a cheap box spring alternative, but they do not provide extra height to your bed.
- Increase the life of your mattress
- Provide additional storage space underneath the bed
- Better air circulation to the mattress helps prevent night sweats
- Inexpensive and widely available
- As compared to metal slats, wood slats can bend over time
- The need for wood slats to fit your bed frame otherwise they will not sit properly
- Might break under the excessive weight of the mattress and the sleeper
10. DIY box spring alternative
The afore-mentioned alternatives to box springs are the perfect way to replace a box spring. However, some of these alternatives might still incur some damage to your wallet. What is the right solution to minimize these costs without compromising on your comfort, then?
We suggest that you choose to build your own bed base rather than head to the market and fuss over an expensive alternative to box spring.
Gather up a few wooden planks, cut them to the size of the dimensions of your bed frame and mattress. Join these slats and lay them horizontally across the frame of your bed. Your DIY box spring alternative is ready to support your mattress!
You can also choose to recycle wood crates, to create a DIY box spring alternative.
1. Can you use plywood instead of a box spring?
If you are not too keen on shelling out a few extra dollars on a box spring, then you can use a plywood sheet to support your mattress. It can be safely said that plywood sheets are a cheap box spring alternative, and it works too! However, make sure that the plywood sheet is of sound quality and should be thicker than ¾ of an inch. A plywood sheet that is less than ¾ inch might rupture, as it would not be able to support the weight of the mattress and the sleepers.
2. What beds do not need a box spring?
Platform beds generally do not require the support of a box spring. Since platform beds double as a bed base, it cancels the need for an additional bed base such as a box spring. Even though platform beds are low in elevation, they come with built-in wooden slats that help support your mattress. Canopy beds, upholstered beds, and sleigh beds usually require the support of a box spring.
3. Are box springs obsolete?
Box springs came around the late nineteenth century. They were made to support mattresses and to prevent them from sulking. Lately, hybrid mattresses and mattresses installed with innerspring have become a norm. These mattresses do just fine without a box spring and are enough on their own. As a result, box springs have become an old-school bed base.
4. How much should a queen box spring cost?
If these innovative box spring alternative ideas don’t sit well with you, then you can invest in a traditional box spring. How much budget should you allocate for such a purchase?
Box springs can generally set you back a few hundred dollars. Depending on the material, make and model, a decent box spring usually costs somewhere between $100 and $250. If you are unfazed by cheap box spring alternatives, then box spring prices can go as high as $800.
When it comes to deciding which is the better option: Boxspring or alternatives to box spring. The answer lies with you. You are the better judge of whether you like an elevated bed base or are you comfortable with a low profile bed. Are you willing to shell out your hard-earned money on a box spring, or are you willing to invest in a hybrid mattress? Do you want to extend the life of your mattress or are you fine with spreading your mattress on the floor?
In the end, it all boils down to the level of comfort, support, and flexibility that you are looking for. This article sums up why you need a box spring or why should you consider other alternatives to box springs.